|
A comprehensive
review of a new small internet radio sold on eBay as a "Sovos"
and in the UK by Ebuyer.com as a "Foehn & Hirsch".
A possible replacement for the
long in the tooth LogikIR100
internet radio?

Just over half the size of a Sky remote control, this new radio receives
internet and FM radio stations.
As you will see from other pages on this web site I
have been using the well known Logik IR100 Internet Radio for more than
5 years and run no less then 5 of them at home. I was recently
introduced to a new internet radio that was being sold on eBay for about
£70 as a Sovos make. Then the well known internet suppler Ebuyer.com imported a
20' container load
under their "home brand" Foehn & Hirsch, and is presently selling them on
"Special Offer" for £50. It's worth reporting the eBay sellers
have responded by making the price of their sets £100. Most odd as these
radios are exactly, precisely the same inside.
After some prevaricating and after point out that we
now get more than 2000 visitors a day I managed to get Ebuyer to
send me a radio to review here. They did not impose any restrictions on
what I wrote, and as you will read I have certainly not held back on my
criticisms!
Let's start by explaining what an internet radio is. Like
many computer things, it's simple really. When you connect to the
internet with your computer you often find that you can listen to
various radio stations from all over the world. Even the BBC are in on
the act and you can listen to their old shows that have been broadcast
in the preceding week (but not on this radio - more on this later.)
Put the bits that make listening to the radio on a
computer together in a small box and that is an internet radio! Radio
stations from all over the world, rather like an old short wave radio,
but in Hi-Fi quality with no whistles, pops or fading. All you need at home is
your existing common or garden wireless router - the same as you are
using now to look at the internet. You need touch nothing or alter any
settings on this and you don't even need to switch your computer on at
all to listen to the radio. Ideal for listening to overseas radio station in bed.
For the last 5 years I have had these sorts of radios
all over my house (as well as beside my bed) so that I can listen to
for example to "hula-hula" music from Matariki FM in the Cook Islands,
the Pacific Ocean, or Angel Radio in Havant anywhere that I
happen to be. An added feature is the ability to listen to any of the
music on my computer on the self same internet radio (but not on this radio).
The main difference between the Logik and the present
review radio is that this one is battery powered which opens the prospect of listening to
the same sort of stations all over my home and even in the bathroom or in the garden in summer. Do I like it and
would I recommend this as a replacement for my Logik IR100 radios that
are beginning to show their age? Well the answer is yes and no, as it
really depends on what you use your internet radio for. If you just
listen to the radio yes, if you like BBC listen again or your own home recordings
then unfortunately the answer is
a resounding no.
You see if you like to listen to your own music or to the
replays of programmes which are available on the BBC IPlayer then you
will have to look elsewhere as this small radio does not even see your
home network at all, let alone will it play Real encoded content that BBC
listen again uses. Very, very annoying as that is mostly what I use my
Logik radios for. These features could certainly be made available as
the radio has a facility for a firmware upade - and you could even
switch between the two operating systems - very advanced!
The radio itself has the feel of being well built and
solid. It is truly palm size measuring just 73 x 125 x 23 cm and weighing only
160g., in English that's about 5 x 3 x 1 inches and 5 ounces! About half the
length and the same thickness and weight as a Sky remote control. It has
a built in rechargeable battery which the makers claim will last for 15
hours before needing recharging. The internal battery is soldered in and
is completely non replaceable. Like the rest of the set it has a guarantee
time of just 1 year. Welcome to the modern throw away society. You could
say that this at least saves on buying batteries, but
guess what, they do not include a charger in the box! You are expected
to use the supplied lead and recharge the radio from the USB socket on
your computer. Given a full recharge can easily take 6 hours - mine
takes quite a lot longer - it seems a
huge waste of electricity. Fortunately the power socket is the same as
the one that I use to recharge my mobile phone (it's a standard small
USB) and I happened to have that charger to hand. This seems to be the
way things are going as my daughter recently bought a new mobile phone
and this too did not come with a charger either. I will at this point
ask a question. Why on earth would you put the power supply socket on
the bottom of any radio? It means that you can't stand it up on a table
and continue to listen. Plain stupid!
Another reason why I nearly threw the radio back into the box when I
first received it was that even after charging for 6 hours it just would not
switch on. I tried pressing the hidden reset button under the plastic
cover beside the power
socket, uttered several oaths, but the radio stubbornly remained dead. I even
(gasp) looked in the instruction book - this is well written and in good
English by the way - but it did not offer any suggestions. It was only after studying the side of the radio
that I found a lock button. Presumably to save the unit switching itself
on during its journey over here from China the makers had locked the unit. A flick
of this switch as I was in! There is a very bright green stripe on the
front that illuminates whenever the radio is on - it flashes red when
the battery is getting low. Apart from wasting power, it's in my
opinion, far too bright - especially at night.
The firmware (which is upgradeable) is well designed. The entry of the wireless
code to connect to my router was easy with minimum button twiddling, and the radio connected immediately.
I've tried it with Netgear, Belkin, BT and Sky routers, all work with
this radio. The radio can store
three networks and connect to them automatically as you move from area
to area so you could for example take it to work with you and have it
reconnect automatically. I must say the Wi-Fi
sensitivity leaves something to be desired as it would not connect from
corners of my home that a laptop can, but I then found there is a way to
boost the signal. It's hidden in the menus as a battery saving setting. Untick this and the Wi-Fi range is much improved,
FM sensitivity stays a little low however.
Unfortunately the
radio defaulted to a test station that is probably only available in the
factory when I switched on so the first thing that I saw was an error
code, but I soon found my way around and had BBC Radio blaring out. The
speaker is small and lacks bass but there is a standard headphone socket
and the audio from here is almost equal to that from the Logik save for
some digital hash that is discussed later. Always
remembering that audio quality is very dependant on the broadcast
encoding. Virgin Radio which uses a high bit rate was excellent, however
the loudspeaker audio from this radio in no way even comes close to that from the
Logik with its hard wooden cabinet and large loudspeaker. No the
audio from the built in loudspeaker is not good.
I should add that I am now hearing some slight
bubbling in the background, especially noticeable when using good
quality headphones. Now the designers of any cross over equipment will
always have problems with digital hash getting into audio circuits but
Logik managed to keep the two apart. It is probably the small size that
makes screening well nigh impossible on this set but you might be
unhappy with the sound if you were to connect the radio to your Hi-Fi.
I'd be interested to hear if others notice the problem of whether it is
confined to the review receiver.
I must praise the speed with which the radio actually
connects to internet radio stations. My Logik radios can take easily 30
seconds to lock up on some low bit rate stations but the F&H is virtually
instant. There is a well designed and comprehensive web site which
allows you to add stations that are not otherwise listed, add favourites that you
find yourself, and adjust many other settings. Unfortunately it would not
be possible for intended users to look beyond the front page of the web site before buying
their radio as it will not let you in until you register, And to
register you need a code from a radio! It's unfortunate but I suppose
helps keep the riff raff out until they pay their money and buy a set!
The screen is quite small and I needed my glasses to
see it clearly (I am old!). It does not show the programme details,
presenter or track listing that the Logik can if it has been upgraded,
this is a pity. You do see the name of the station and the buffering
level if the internet connection or reception is iffy. To save power the
screen blanks after a preset time - maximum 30 seconds - probably a good
idea to save battery power but I'd have like to be able to leave it
permanently powered when running on the mains. Selection is by a
combination of the "twiddler" on the front - on my radio it's
got a very cheap
and nasty feel to it - plus a "back" button on the top.
It is only fair to mention that at the top of the
display is a number that supposedly shows the bit rate at which the
station is transmitting. For example a South Seas station with a slow
connection to the outside world might use 32kbps, the BBC use 44.1k,
whereas someone like Virgin Radio who have a number of audiophiles
listening transmits at no less than 192k. I can't personally hear much
difference once the rate gets above 64k, but that's being old for you!
The trouble is the display on this radio is most certainly idiosyncratic
as it seems to show bit rates that it makes up itself! They are
certainly completely wrong as I have my own small station and know what
rate I send at - the radio disagrees! This can no doubt be sorted out on
a firmware update but needs addressing.
I did not mention that this radio also has a standard
FM tuner. Reception to me was extremely weak, not locking up stations
that all my other radios can tune to with ease. It is not helped by the
automated tuning system which only stops on strong signals. Needs work
in my opinion. There is no firmware update on offer as I type this,
perhaps none will come until they see if the radio will sell in
quantity. Like other internet radios the whole concept needs clearly
explaining o a techno phobic public who would mostly run a mile from
having to enter a hexadecimal code..
As I mentioned above I received my review receiver,
but the question still arises whether I would pay the £50 "Special
Offer" price that Ebuyer are presently charging, let alone £100 to
get it from China on line. I suppose at £50 I would buy it,
just. I use my Logik radio mostly for listen again and local music which
the F&H radio will not presently handle, so it's a close decision,
but the ability to carry the set with me and even into the garden swings
it. If
and when they upgrade the firmware to include the missing features (and it
should not be that difficult to arrange) then buying this radio for 50 quid would
be a no brainer.
Before closing this review I must mention a possible
use for this receiver which is different from the design. Some of us who
work with computers need to check if a wireless network is operational
and whether it has a good range. Up until now this has either meant
carrying you laptop up and down stairs whilst trying to look at the
screen or risking upsetting your phone settings to search for
networks. Now this
radio offers an alternative. You can whip it out of your pocket and scan for
wireless networks to your hearts content. The battery will last for days
or weeks of intermittent use, it would not be the end of the world if
you were to leave it somewhere, and you can even check the network security
settings! Now I know that I said before that the Wi-Fi sensitivity was
not wonderful, but thinking about it this might be an advantage as if
this radio can see a network you can be almost certain that a laptop
will! If you are in the computer networking business this use alone might make purchase essential!
This radio is available from several sellers on eBay
or on Ebuyer.com where the product number is 227272. If you can wait for
up to 5 days then delivery is free, otherwise the charge
is about £10 for overnight. I can recommend Ebuyer as an honest UK based
internet trader who can be relied upon. |